• Shoutbox
    Active Users: 0
  • Notice: N/A
    NFLfans processing...
Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: Should Vikings Sign George Iloka

  1. #1

    Should Vikings Sign George Iloka

    By Ted Glover purplebuckeye March 2, 2016

    Yesterday, Cincinnati Bengals S George Iloka became an unrestricted free agent when Cincinnati did not use a franchise or transition tag on him. It was kind of a surprise non-move, as Iloka is a big part of their defense, and considered one of the top safeties in the NFL

    Iloka is going to be one of the most hotly pursued free agents on the market when free agency begins. He was a fifth round draft choice in 2012, and has been starting for the Bengals since 2013. He's one of the premier safeties in the NFL, and for comparison sake, let's use Pro Football Focus' overall grading system to compare and contrast. Iloka came in 15th overall in PFF's system, grading out at 82.6. All Pro Harrison Smith, the number one safety in their rankings, graded out at 92.8. When you consider the safety play opposite Smith (Andrew Sendejo was 85th overall with a grade of 52.0) to say Iloka would be an upgrade is a massive understatement.

    Why This Makes Sense

    The safety position opposite Smith is a gaping black hole on an otherwise stout defense. A starting tandem of Smith and Iloka would take a good secondary and make it, at least on paper, an elite one, and arguably the best secondary in the NFL. With a division full of talented quarterbacks, a deep and talented secondary at all positions is essential, and Iloka would be a coup for Mike Zimmer and company. And let's not forget Iloka was coached by Zimmer for three years, and it was Zimmer that made him a starter one year after he was a fifth round pick. When you add in the fact that players love the guy and want to play for him, which Iloka pretty much said in the interview, the Vikings being a team on the rise, and enough salary cap room to do a deal, the Vikings and Iloka seem like a natural fit.

    Why This Doesn't Make Sense

    Yeah, let's talk salary. The Vikings are going to need to re-do Harrison Smith's contract soon, and he's going to get paid. The franchise tag number for safeties this year was $10.8 million, so if we use Earl Thomas' contract as a guide, let's say that he'll get a deal somewhere in the $8-9 million range per season, with about $27-28 million guaranteed, roughly speaking. Iloka might not command that kind of number in a re-negotiation if he were under contract like Smith is, but free agency is a time when teams pay stupid money to massively overpay for players. Could Iloka command more than $8/27 from a team like the Browns, or another suitor? Yeah, he could. And would the Vikings go that high? Man, I'm having a tough time saying 'yes' to that, and having approximately $20 million tied up at the safety position.

    Likelihood Of Iloka Signing With The Vikings

    All that aside, Iloka to the Vikings makes a ton of sense, both from a football and personal relationship perspective. Unless a team like Cleveland were to come in and break the bank for him, the Vikings will have enough room under the salary cap to get him if they want him. When you add in the relationship he has with Mike Zimmer from their time together in Cincinnati, this is probably the one free agent rumor I'd believe over any other player to any other team, at least at this point of the process.

  2. #2
    Yeah, he would cost a lot of money, but we could free some up by dumping some dead weight offensive linemen. I would love to see them sign him but the point about teams with loads of money to spend is valid. Jacksonville and Oakland both need to sign some big money guys and Iloka is young and talented, so I see him going somewhere like that. We'll more likely draft a safety that is capable of starting and (hopefully) use Sendejo sparingly there while the rookie learns enough to take it for himself.

  3. #3
    Iloka would cost a lot and I'm guessing that the Vikes won't spend that much on the safety position. Maybe Iloka will give his former coach a huge "I love you man" discount (Yeah, I'm not holding my breath either).

    If we can't sign a free agent then I hope that we draft a SS in 2nd or 3rd round. Otherwise I don't see drafting anyone latter that is going to step in and start anytime soon. Sendejo is a very good special teams player and would be an adequate reserve SS but as a starter he ranked as one of the worst last year according to PFF.

    Either through free agency or the draft the Vikes need to invest a little more in the position than they have in the past.

  4. #4
    There are cheaper options, though not as good probably. Rashad Johnson from Arizona, Tashaun Gipsen from Cleveland, Reggie Nelson from Cincy.

  5. #5
    Just read that the Vikings are interested in Reggie Nelson. The Falcons are also interested in Nelson.

  6. #6
    Take Iloka off the list. He reportedly resigned with Cincinnati for 5 years and $30 million.

  7. #7
    Guys seem to like playing in Cincinnati for some reason. I think we could have given him that contract. Oh well, maybe we're not done with Nelson, and I'm sure we'll draft one too.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO